« From Time Out New York | Main | A Quick Check-In »

December 04, 2008

From Real Detroit

Stella's Michael Ian Black + Michael Showalter
The State Of Comedy

Comedy is no longer comedy. Comedy is now the art of the anti-delivery, the telling of the pseudo-joke tangled within an awkward silence as we wait for the punch line. But the punch line no longer arrives with an off-tempo comedic styling, rather it doesn't arrive at all. Humor is not delivered as straightforward as it used to be, but twice as observational as ever, leaving the audience to examine themselves instead of laughing at the distant yet relative blunders of others. Half the time, we probably “just won’t get it,” but this whole phenomenon of letting the awkward realities of life speak for themselves instead of packaging them inside a meat-and-potatoes joke is so mainstream and common that comedians who still play within the envelope are considered a bit boring and left to wallow under the radar. While Dane Cook’s superhuman stage presence coupled with point A to point B in-depth inspections of blue humor, clumsy romance and sexual encounters has put him at the top of his craft, comedians like Michael Showalter and Michael Ian Black are so deadpan and heavily rooted in uncomfortable pragmatism that we’re left to wonder where and when the joke started and if it ever ended. It’s Andy Kaufman rising from the grave. And while the average observer might not be able to catch it, there is still an ounce of practical performance left within Stella’s stage show (and ill-fated Comedy Central series of the same name that starred Black, Showalter and third member, David Wain) that occasionally helps the ill at ease become embarrassingly relatable and comically memorable.

“One of the things about Stella that was hard for an audience to get was the layer of reality hanging over that show that people didn’t understand,” explains Showalter, as he gets ready to treat his friends and family to a massive Thanksgiving dinner before heading out on tour with Wain and Black. "A lot of the time, the joke in Stella was that we were doing the joke at all. Mainly because of the Internet, comedy is now somewhat parallel to the music industry in that you have your mainstream artists, or comedians, who have a mass appeal, and then you have a million shades in between it. Those millions of shades used to not be as accessible to everybody, but now they are. There is always going to be a huge appetite for Sinbad, but there is a parallel that they want the same thing in comedy as they do in indie music … something a bit harder to figure out. Newer comedians are experimenting with the idea that there are other ways to be funny than just telling jokes and hitting the punch lines.”

“Any sort of artistic movement in any genre is largely fueled by a reaction,” explains Black who, after conducting what would ultimately serve as a preliminary interview, finally ditched his shtick to talk about the changing of the guard in the comedy world. “When I started performing comedy, the primary comedic style — sometimes exclusive comedic style — was the Jerry Seinfeld school, where you were making cool observational humor about the stupidity of every day life … sports jacket, sleeves rolled up, basic cable comedy. [Anti-comedy] was a reaction to all of that.”

This was ’88, and all three members of soon-to-be comedy trio Stella were freshmen at New York University, hungry to pursue improv and sketch comedy. While Black only recalls being “17-years-old and not knowing anything,” Showalter remembers the three of them being extremely “interested in live performance” and exploring new parameters of comedy. But Showalter and Black do agree on one thing — Wain was kind of a prick. “He was a cock to everybody,” says Black, “because he believed himself to be in a superior sketch group. Plus, he was a sophomore while we were freshmen so he lorded his own greatness over us. But, of course, he ended up begging to be in our sketch group.”

Both before and after Stella came to fruition, the trio would collectively and separately pursue the entertainment industry with astonishing success. Showalter’s biggest claim to fame remains the cult classic Wet, Hot American Summer while Black is best known as a talking head on various VH1 series (as well as writer of Run, Fat Boy, Run and most recently a children’s book). Wain has yet to stop bragging about the success of Role Models, a movie that he both directed and co-wrote.

While their pursuits outside of Stella remain commercially viable, the comedy troupe stands as a testament to the sort of comedy that wins the popular vote today — crossing humor with awkward reality to a point where no one is quite sure when the joke begins and ends. This leaves the audience to wonder — where does the reality for Showalter and Black begin and end? How much of themselves are they presenting on stage, and how much of their public persona is an illusion?

“I’ve always been interested in … the separation between a performer as they presented themselves in public and how they are in private, and the mythology they created around those personas," says Black. "There’s fact and there’s fiction, and I don’t generally reveal what’s what.” While Stella’s performance is a prime example of artistic fluidity, Showalter has a wildly different perspective on the matter. “I just like to be myself,” explains Showalter who, throughout the interview, has expressed excitement for how full circle his career has become — he currently teaches screenwriting at New York University’s Graduate Film School. “I find that I’m more interested in what’s true. In my sense of humor and the work that I do, I’m trying to establish a thin line between my character and who I really am.”

“I’ve never watched a performance,” adds Black, “and thought to myself that I was seeing the totality of a human being. I don’t know what obligation a stand-up comic has to show the entirety of their personality with the audience. Certainly someone like Jerry Seinfeld doesn’t. He’s essentially a blank slate and, consequentially, I don’t find him that interesting.” RDW


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference From Real Detroit :


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


I cant tell if this is positive or negative towards you guys.

Stacey E

It's nice that they made reference to Andy Kaufman, since he was the only performance artist worth talking about. They failed to mention that a lot of people "hate" Dane Cook. Oh well.
He's no David Sedaris, that's for sure.


All this "media buzz" has got me wet in anticipation for the Stella show on the 13th... dripping.


Well, aren't we the media whores right now? And quite right too.


Gross Nicky!

I love this line: "Wain has yet to stop bragging about the success of Role Models" haha. Also, you dropped your schtick? I will pick it up for you and put it in a glass box, and stare at it for 3 hours every day.

I love this review. Stella as postmodern comedy. Deconstructed and playful, poking fun at comedy itself. Anti-comedy. Good job boys, you indie-comics you, I want to pinch your cheeks and your big fat funny brains! xxoo


Shallow push!!


Thanks for the funny interviews.

And pretty please give this not so cryptic but very important (to me at least) msg to David: "That email you sent did not go through - please help"


Favorite thing about this article = "and third member, David Wain"

Clayton Tillotson

This is the first time I've ever heard someone describe the comedy of Stella from the view of something like Comedic Theory! Haha it's so cool though because I'm always thinking that. You guys are all so innovative. It's really disappointing when people don't get it. They just want to be fed funny little things.


"There’s fact and there’s fiction, and I don’t generally reveal what’s what.”

^and this is what makes your blogs endlessly fascinating. Keep on keepin' on.


What's this "preliminary interview" you gave that the writer mentions? I want me some of that.

The comments to this entry are closed.